Mrs. Keller adjusted her glasses, leaning forward to examine the photo.
“Oh, I remember that day clearly. It was my grandniece’s birthday.”
She tapped the image with a gnarled finger.
“Your Nathan was quite busy coming and going with his truck several times, carrying all those supplies.”
Lauren felt her chest tighten.
“Are you certain about the date? Nathan specifically mentioned the Springfield auction that morning. I remember because he asked me to call him if any buyer stopped by about the John Deere tractor. He even left the auction catalog on the kitchen counter.”
Mrs. Keller nodded firmly, her expression resolute.
“I’m absolutely certain. My grandniece turned 12 on July 15th. Got her those roller skates she wanted.”
She adjusted her glasses again, peering at the photo.
“This picture was taken that afternoon around 4:00. Mark never would have approved of construction without consulting you first. Always said a farm was a partnership.”
The unspoken comparison hung in the air between them.
Lauren traced the outline of Nathan in the photograph with her fingertip. He was partially turned away from the camera, his face in profile as he carried a long piece of lumber toward the barn.
What was he building that day?
And why had he lied about being at an auction?
Back at home, Lauren decided to organize the farm tax documents, hoping the task might distract her from thoughts of the twins. Nathan had been handling finances since Mark’s death, but perhaps helping with paperwork could lighten his load. She retrieved the accordion folder from the file cabinet in the study and spread the contents across the kitchen table.
As she sorted through banking records, she paused at several credit-card charges she did not recognize. Building supplies from Handover Hardware, a ventilation system from Midwest Agricultural Supply, and something listed as acoustic materials from a specialty retailer she had never heard of, all purchased in the weeks before the twins disappeared.
Her brow furrowed in confusion. The farm did not need soundproofing.
Lauren stared at the receipts spread across the kitchen table. Were those legitimate farm expenses, or was Nathan using farm money for personal projects? Mark had always been transparent about every penny spent, consulting her on purchases as small as a new set of work gloves. Those purchases seemed secretive by comparison, made without any discussion.
She felt a growing suspicion that Nathan might be taking advantage of her distraction to siphon money from the farm.
The thought brought a wave of guilt.
Nathan had been her support system since Mark’s death, stepping in to run the farm and help with the twins. Without him, she might have lost everything. But the evidence before her suggested he might not be the selfless brother-in-law she had believed him to be.
When Nathan’s truck rumbled up the driveway that evening, Lauren hastily gathered the receipts and tucked them back into the folder. She was not ready to confront him directly, not without more information.
Instead, she prepared dinner as usual, trying to act normal as they sat across from each other at the kitchen table.
“The pot roast is good,” Nathan said, breaking the silence. His voice was tired, his eyes shadowed from what he described as a long day of deliveries. “You’re getting your appetite back. That’s good to see.”
Lauren nodded, pushing food around her plate. She waited until he had taken a few more bites before casually mentioning, “Detective Rivera called today. He had a question about your Milfield delivery on the day the girls disappeared.”
She watched Nathan’s reaction carefully. His fork paused briefly midair before completing its journey to his mouth. If she had not been looking for it, she might have missed the momentary hesitation.
“What about it?” he asked after swallowing.
“The market manager said our farm didn’t have a booth that day.”
Nathan set his fork down and reached for his water glass, taking a long drink before responding.
“He must have been thinking of last month’s schedule,” he said with a shrug that seemed just slightly too rehearsed. “Rivera should focus on actual leads instead of wasting time on calendar mix-ups.”
He quickly changed the subject to the weather forecast, commenting on the possibility of rain later in the week. Lauren nodded and made appropriate responses, but her mind was cataloguing his reaction, adding it to her growing list of concerns.
“I should turn in early,” Nathan announced as he carried his plate to the sink. “Got an early delivery run tomorrow.”
Lauren began clearing the rest of the table.
“The search teams with dogs will be doing another sweep at first light.”
Something flashed across Nathan’s face, frustration, annoyance. It was gone so quickly she almost thought she had imagined it.
“Another search?” he said softly, his back to her as he rinsed his plate. “It’s been 2 months, Lauren. They should be looking elsewhere by now.”
His words seemed reasonable on the surface. After 2 months, the chances of finding the twins were statistically low. But something in his tone set off alarm bells in Lauren’s mind.
Why would he want the searches to stop?
Unable to sleep that night, Lauren stared at the ceiling, the day’s inconsistencies churning in her mind, the strange purchases, Nathan’s lie about the auction, the delivery to Milfield that had not happened. Each might be insignificant alone, but together they formed a pattern she could not ignore.
She turned to look at the clock on her bedside table.
11:40 p.m.
The house was silent except for the occasional creak of the old farmhouse settling. Nathan’s room was down the hall. He had moved in after Mark’s death to help with the farm and had stayed to support her after the twins disappeared. Now she wondered if his continued presence served another purpose entirely.
As Lauren lay in the darkness, the sudden rumble of an engine broke the night’s silence. She sat up, listening. The distinctive sound of Nathan’s truck starting up outside sent a jolt of adrenaline through her body. Through her window, she watched his headlights move toward the barn rather than the main road.
Her hand trembled on the windowsill as she watched Nathan’s truck head toward the barn. For a moment she saw him as he had been at Mark’s funeral, the steady presence who had held her upright when her knees buckled at the graveside. Then the image shifted to the falsified delivery records, the secret purchases, his evasive eyes when questioned.
“He wouldn’t,” she whispered to the empty room.
But another voice in her mind responded.
Wouldn’t he?
Her fingers hovered over her phone, doubt paralyzing her. Nathan had been her rock, managing the farm, dealing with authorities, supporting her through the darkest period of her life. What if she was wrong? What if that midnight errand had a perfectly innocent explanation? The thought of betraying his trust with suspicion made her stomach twist with shame.
But then she thought of the discrepancies Detective Rivera had mentioned, the strange purchases, Nathan’s lie about his whereabouts. The math did not add up. Her children were still missing.
What if Nathan knew something he was not sharing?
What if he had been lying about more than just his whereabouts?
The possibility, however remote, was enough.
Lauren dialed Mrs. Keller, speaking in hushed tones as she moved away from the window.
“Mrs. Keller, I’m sorry to call so late.”
“Lauren, what’s wrong, dear?” the elderly woman’s voice was alert despite the hour.
“Nathan just went to the barn,” she whispered, peeking through the curtains to confirm that his truck was still parked outside the structure. “It’s almost midnight.”
There was a pause on the line before Mrs. Keller responded.
“Do you think he’s hiding something?”
Lauren explained about the search teams coming in the morning and the strange credit-card charges she had found earlier.
“Building supplies, ventilation equipment, things we don’t need,” she added, her voice trembling slightly. “Now this midnight trip to the barn. I was going to follow him.”
“Be careful,” Mrs. Keller warned, her voice sharp with concern. “If he’s moving farm equipment or supplies, you’ll need proof. Keep your distance and just observe.”
“Should I call Detective Rivera?” Lauren asked, already pulling on a pair of jeans over her pajama bottoms.
“Not yet,” Mrs. Keller advised. “You need evidence first. Just see what he’s doing.”
Lauren promised she would be careful and ended the call. As she slipped out of bed, guilt and determination warred within her. Guilt at suspecting the man who had shouldered her burdens. Determination to find any clue about her missing daughters.
She pulled on her robe and boots. Each movement was a conscious choice to trust her instincts over her loyalty to Nathan. Moving quietly through the kitchen, she grabbed a small flashlight from the drawer, but decided not to turn it on yet. Moonlight provided enough visibility as she followed the path toward the barn where Nathan’s truck was parked, her heart hammering with the terrible possibility that she was about to uncover a betrayal worse than she had ever imagined.
The night air was cool against her skin, carrying the scent of freshly cut hay and the earthy smell of the nearby fields. Lauren’s heart pounded in her chest as she approached the barn, staying close to the shadows of the old oak tree that had stood sentinel beside the structure for generations.
Through the partially opened barn door, she saw Nathan straining to move 1 of the large rectangular hay bales at the back of the barn. His muscles flexed as he managed to slide it several feet to the side.
Lauren crouched lower, watching intently. The twins used to play around those hay bales, building forts and hiding spots during rainy afternoons. Now Nathan was treating them with an urgency that seemed out of place for simple farm maintenance.
He reached into his truck bed and pulled out several plastic bags, then began spreading something around the hay bale and throughout the barn. Lauren caught sight of the label on 1 of the bags as Nathan set it down before returning to his truck for more.
Vermguard.
When he stepped out to get something else from his vehicle, Lauren quickly pulled out her phone and searched for Vermguard. The results confirmed it was a commercial-grade rodent repellent.
Relief washed over her briefly.
Maybe Nathan was just trying to protect her from worry about a rat infestation. He was always shielding her from farm problems, especially since the twins disappeared. She felt a pang of guilt for suspecting him of financial wrongdoing when he might just have been handling a pest problem without burdening her.
Hot shame washed over her as she thought of all the ways Nathan had stepped up since Mark’s death, managing the farm alone, supporting her through her grief, organizing search parties for the twins without complaint.
She was about to put her phone away when a product review caught her eye.
Warning to K9 handlers. Vermguard severely affects tracking abilities of service and search dogs. Keeps rats away, but made my guide dog sick for weeks.
Lauren’s throat constricted as she reread the comment. Tomorrow morning, search teams with trained dogs would be sweeping the property again. Why would Nathan spread rodent repellent the night before? Could he be hiding something he did not want the dogs to find?
The financial irregularities, questionable purchases, cash withdrawals, perhaps Nathan had been siphoning money from the farm and hiding evidence in the barn. But a darker thought surfaced in Lauren’s mind, 1 so terrible she could barely acknowledge it. What if Nathan’s midnight activities had nothing to do with money at all?
Lauren watched as Nathan scanned the yard before climbing into his truck. The engine started and headlights cut through the darkness as he drove toward the house. Lauren remained frozen behind the oak tree, caught between loyalty and suspicion. If he had been embezzling from the farm, especially from the twins’ college fund, she needed to know. But the growing knot in her stomach suggested something far worse might be at stake.
She waited until Nathan’s truck disappeared around the bend, then stood on shaky legs. Taking a deep breath, Lauren moved forward, driven by a mother’s responsibility to protect what remained of her family’s security. With trembling fingers, she switched on her small flashlight and stepped inside the barn, determined to uncover whatever Nathan was trying to keep hidden.
The barn seemed different at night, filled with looming shadows that stretched across the worn wooden floor. Lauren made her way carefully to the back corner where she had seen Nathan working earlier. The smell was overwhelming, a sharp chemical odor from the Vermguard substance Nathan had so carefully spread around the area, mixing with the familiar scent of hay and the musty undertone of decades-old wood.
Lauren covered her nose with her sleeve, her eyes watering slightly from the potent aroma as she approached the suspicious area. Swinging her flashlight beam around the space, she noticed how the hay bales were stacked too neatly, too deliberately, forming a perfect rectangle over a section of the floor that seemed slightly discolored compared to the surrounding boards.
Lauren traced the pattern of the Vermguard granules with her light, noting how the surrounding area was liberally covered with the dark substance, creating a distinct pattern that seemed designed to draw attention away from those particular bales. She remembered the online comment about scent detection and dogs, and her stomach tightened with dread. Nathan was not just hiding financial documents. This was something much more significant.
She ran her hands along the edge of 1 hay bale, noticing how freshly cut it felt compared to the others stored in the barn. The twins had loved playing hide-and-seek among the older bales, their laughter echoing through the cavernous space as they found increasingly creative hiding spots. The memory sent a fresh wave of grief through her, momentarily stopping her breath.
She pushed against the bale experimentally, finding it slid more easily than its weight would suggest. Drawing on strength she did not know she had, Lauren began moving the bales 1 by 1, her muscles straining with each push. Sweat beaded on her forehead despite the cool night air, and her breathing became labored as she worked, constantly glancing toward the barn entrance, terrified that Nathan might return.
As she pushed aside the final hay bale, she discovered a section of flooring that did not match the rest, a perfectly camouflaged hatch with carefully disguised hinges, nearly invisible when covered by hay. The wood was newer, stained to match the surrounding planks, but the grain pattern did not align with the century-old floorboards around it.
Her hands shook as she found the hidden edge and pulled, her heart pounding so loudly she feared it might alert Nathan all the way back at the house. The hatch was heavy but rose on silent hinges, revealing a ladder descending into darkness.
This was what the building supplies were for, she realized with growing horror.
Not embezzlement.
Leave a Comment